A company that owns a portion of the copyright to Bruno Mars’ “When I Was Your Man” points to overwhelming similarities between the two tracks.
Miley Cyrus performs onstage during the 66th Grammy Awards. Kevin Winter/Getty Images
Miley Cyrus has been sued for allegedly ripping off Bruno Mars’ “When I Was Your Man” for her Grammy-winning hit song “Flowers.”
The lawsuit, filed in California federal court on Monday, was brought by Tempo Music Investments, which acquired in 2020 a share of the copyright to the Mars track from songwriter Philip Lawrence. It accuses Cyrus of “intentional copying” constituting infringement.
Songwriters Gregory Hein and Michael Pollock, who cowrote the song with Cyrus, Sony Music Publishing, and distributors of the song, including Apple, Live Nation and Amazon, were also named in the complaint, which doesn’t involve Mars on either side.
“Flowers,” written after Cyrus’ divorce with Liam Hemsworth, became an overnight hit when it debuted in January 2023 at the top of the Billboard Hot 100 chart, where it stayed for eight weeks. A year later, it earned Cyrus her first Grammy.
Similarities between the two tracks were immediately apparent. Cyrus’ song is regarded by many listeners as an interpolation of “When I Was Your Man,” which was released in 2013.
Tempo Music’s complaint alleges “Flowers” is an unauthorized derivative of Mars’ record. It points to substantial similarities in the melody, harmony and chorus.
“Indeed, the opening vocal line from the chorus of ‘Flowers’ begins and ends on the same chords as the opening vocal line in the verse of ‘When I was Your Man.’” states the complaint.
The lawsuit details overlaps in the melodic designs of the songs, which Tempo Music says share the same “musical fingerprint.” It also cites a side-by-side comparison of the lyrics. While Mars sings “That I should have brought you flowers and held your hand,” Cyrus sings “I can buy myself flowers and I can hold my own hand,” for instance.
“A comparison of the lyrics of the two songs also suggests that the musical similarities are no coincidence,” writes Alex Weingarten, a lawyer for the company, in the complaint.
In the case, Cyrus may argue that she’s protected by fair use, which provides protection for the use of copyrighted material to make a secondary work as long as it’s “transformative.”
News
How Liam Hemsworth got the last laugh in his divorce from Miley Cyrus – as her song about their split is accused of being a ripoff
Liam Hemsworth is getting the last laugh in his divorce from Miley Cyrus, after her blistering breakup song Flowers was accused of being a ripoff. The Hunger Games actor, 34, was married to Miley, 31, from 2018 to 2020, and three years after…
Miley Cyrus sued over Grammy-winning hit ‘Flowers’ for allegedly copying Bruno Mars song
Copyright Credit: AP Photo The lawsuit claims that her Grammy-winning hit copies lyrical and melodic elements from Bruno Mars’ 2013 song ‘When I Was Your Man’. Pop megastar Miley Cyrus is facing a lawsuit over claims that her 2023 hit ‘Flowers’ borrows from…
EXCLUSIVEWhy Liam Hemsworth is Miley Cyrus’ biggest fear in copyright lawsuit after she is SUED for allegedly ripping a Bruno Mars hit for her Grammy-winning song Flowers
Miley Cyrus is worried she will have to ‘publicly reveal’ that ex-husband Liam Hemsworth is the ‘inspiration’ behind her 2023 track, Flowers, after she was sued for copyright infringement. The 31-year-old pop star was hit with a lawsuit accusing her of copying Bruno Mars’…
MasterChef 5: perché ha vinto Erica, la mamma single. Quello che è successo? Scopriamolo nella sezione commenti….
MasterChef 5: perché ha vinto Erica, la mamma single È Erica Liverani la vincitrice della quinta edizione di MasterChef Italia, il programma culinario di Sky diventato negli anni un vero cult. A decretare la (controversa) vittoria, i super chef Carlo…
Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs charges are ‘a win for women’ says ex-Danity Kane member
Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs charges are ‘a win for women’ says ex-Danity Kane member Aubrey O’Day, formerly of the Combs-produced girl group, had also accused hip-hop mogul of trying to buy her silenceA former member of Sean Combs’s Danity Kane girl…
50 Cent and Foxy Brown Seemingly React to Diddy’s Arrest: ‘About to Really Get Crazy’
50 Cent and Foxy Brown Seemingly React to Diddy’s Arrest: ‘About to Really Get Crazy’ For Your Consideration Event For Starz’s “Power” – Arrivals, 50 Cent: JC Olivera/Getty Images 50 Cent and Foxy Brown are the latest celebrities to react…
End of content
No more pages to load